Xenforo & Wordpress Bridge

Deepmartini

Well-known member
Everyone knows the crap forum called BBpress is like the ugly stepchild of Wordpress, left alone and abandoned. SimplePressForum (a Wordpress Plugin) is a good start but doesn't have the "wow" factor but integrates perfectly with Wordpress.

If Xenforo could release a Wordpress plugin that has full integration with Wordpress including all user information and a single login, it would be a POWERHOUSE. Do you know how many Wordpress sites want to add a forum to their site but can't?

Any mods like this coming?
 
Upvote 55
Hi,

although there are a few Wordpress addon-bridges out there, it seems to me that none of them has (yet) shared theme like other addons i.e. Xenporta 2 or CTA.

I know that Wordpress is extremely good. But I do think that many users actually do not need all the features of Wordpress. I have more the impression, that most XF users want to have the layout of a blog as a frontpage, but the whole "action" shall take place in the XF-Forum and the blog just displays /morrors specific threads on its frontpage.

For me and most likely other users next to this very basic requirement is the shared theme between "the blog" and the XF-Forum. This is the reason why Xeporta 2 and CTA have such a success. They offer both, basic blog functionality with content of XF and no theme work required.

I currently use Joomla as a frontpage. I started with Joomla when Wordpress was not known and really only a basic blog, no CMS as today. And I am sick of upgrading all the time a CMS, fix templates which do never exactly look the same like the XF-Forum theme. My time is wasted by adjusting and fixing things "behind the curtain" as soon as a new version comes out. Either on the CMS side or the forum side. This is not my job as a forum owner. I should use my time with pushing my community traffic and income instead of fixing bugs.

So for me the most important part with an "CMS-addon or bridge" is to save me time by using the content of my forum and using the same template as my forum.

It seems CTA and Xenporta 2 are doeing this already quite good. Xenword will maybe do it in a few years (lacking the tmeplate sharing at the moment) and the other Wordpress bridges seem not be better in this regard. As long as there is no real integration with a Wordpress bridge also with the design/template, it is a no go for me.

The onyl thing that let me hesitate at the moment is, that I am not sure about SEO consequences, if I would only go to CTA / Xenporta 2 route. It seems that Google likes Wordpress. Does Google likes the same way also a Xenporta or CTA front page?

This is very important and the only reason why I would love to have an official Wordpress bridge at all. Best from Xenforo itself to have less bugpotential with the forum and lifetime support.

Very basic as described above but with the same forum template as described above.
 
Last edited:
...
My planning goes out at least 3-5 years and preferably 10...my site has been up for 17 years.

I just cannot build something on an add-on which may be here today and gone next year!
....

Well said. I have no time for experiments. This is why I decided for Xenforo as a forum and pay for it instead of a free phpbb et alii.

Additionally I can not afford to change all my frontpage URLs every 2-3 years because the Blog-addon is not supported anymore...
 
Wow, I have to resurrect this suggestion from the grave - sorry for this. The fact that this thread is so old might be the reason it has so few upvotes. A problem with this type of suggestion system IMHO.

Native integration is something we would really like to see, especially with the 3rd party add-ons falling away. It seems Invision does this natively, and we really wish Xenforo would integrate this option.

Basic options, like sharing logins with users with the idea that WP runs the website, XF is the forums.

Please and thanks!
 
Last edited:
Basic options, like sharing logins with users with the idea that WP runs the website, XF is the forums.
Does this do enough for you.


Themehouse had a Wordpress bridge and a native iOS app that were compatible with each other but they’ve moved on to other things it seems.

Chronic bridge issues are:

Wordpress Cache addons don’t seem to work when bridged.

You need two themes. A Wordpress one and a xenforo one, and it’s hard to get them “to look alike”. Usually needs custom coding.


Wordpress code is outdated and breaks often. Bridge makers have to fix things … a lot.


Good news was xenforo added more robust ways to sync logins ? API ? I forget but it seems it could make a bridge work easier / better.
 
Does this do enough for you.


Themehouse had a Wordpress bridge and a native iOS app that were compatible with each other but they’ve moved on to other things it seems.

Chronic bridge issues are:

Wordpress Cache addons don’t seem to work when bridged.

You need two themes. A Wordpress one and a xenforo one, and it’s hard to get them “to look alike”. Usually needs custom coding.


Wordpress code is outdated and breaks often. Bridge makers have to fix things … a lot.


Good news was xenforo added more robust ways to sync logins ? API ? I forget but it seems it could make a bridge work easier / better.
Yes, thanks for the suggestion, we used this add-on before, but alas, also no longer supported. The Theme House group is awesome, we use several of their add-ons.

XFtoWP was perfect for us. Unfortunately, as previously stated, it seems abandoned and errors are starting to pop up as both WP and XF see updates, forcing me to use post necromancy.

After using XF for over a decade, Xenforo relying 3rd party add-ons, becomes more painful as time moves on, as many of them become abandoned. There are some awesome 3rd Party add-on groups here, but unfortunately, for us, it just takes one add-on that is abandoned, to make us rethink viability of keeping XF forums, beyond the standard install. It is disheartening, frankly.

The lack of native integration of some core features, is really starting to illustrate that Xenforo might not be the forum for us.

Lets take this suggestion as an example. It took me some time to figure out how to even address this issue in the suggestions forum, when my previous attempt were moderated. It was like solving a puzzle in a game - lol - this is NOT good. After my initial post here was removed, I had to carefully decipher what the mod communicated. I even asked how to address address this issue - but it was ignored (yay). Not being one to give up, I searched this forum and I had dig up a post from 2010 (14 year old) to bring up this issue. Lack of built in native features features in Xenforo like this example, means you have to coble systems like this suggestion forum together to get anywhere- I think this is pretty poor user experience to say the least - frankly, have to upvote a thread that 14 years old is TERRIBLE.

I saw a thread, somewhere here on the XF forums discussing how Invision has moved towards cloud servers, closing down their 3rd Party Market Place, increasing their prices, and really doubling down on native integrations. Although I think many may disagree here, for groups like us, this seems like a compelling strategy. Their updates seem much more rapid, and their core install looks extremely feature rich. I only found them by looking to see what forum software other game developers are using, and Invision seems the most popular. So Invision may be much more expensive, but not having to dig, search, and beg for solutions here, is a big upside.

Anyway, we are exploring what our options are in this area now that we hit this snag. As the OP said back in 2010 WP is a huge marketplace, and having native integration for it, and putting something in the WP marketplace for Xenforo, would probably boost adoption for XF.
 
Last edited:
Yes, thanks for the suggestion, we used this add-on before, but alas, also no longer supported. The Theme House group is awesome, we use several of their add-ons.

XFtoWP was perfect for us. Unfortunately, as previously stated, it seems abandoned and errors are starting to pop up as both WP and XF see updates, forcing me to use post necromancy.

After using XF for over a decade, Xenforo relying 3rd party add-ons, becomes more painful as time moves on, as many of them become abandoned. There are some awesome 3rd Party add-on groups here, but unfortunately, for us, it just takes one add-on that is abandoned, to make us rethink viability of keeping XF forums, beyond the standard install. It is disheartening, frankly.

The lack of native integration of some core features, is really starting to illustrate that Xenforo might not be the forum for us.

Lets take this suggestion as an example. It took me some time to figure out how to even address this issue in the suggestions forum, when my previous attempt were moderated. It was like solving a puzzle in a game - lol - this is NOT good. After my initial post here was removed, I had to carefully decipher what the mod communicated. I even asked how to address address this issue - but it was ignored (yay). Not being one to give up, I searched this forum and I had dig up a post from 2010 (14 year old) to bring up this issue. Lack of built in native features features in Xenforo like this example, means you have to coble systems like this suggestion forum together to get anywhere- I think this is pretty poor user experience to say the least - frankly, have to upvote a thread that 14 years old is TERRIBLE.

I saw thread, somewhere here on the XF forums discussing how Invision has moved towards cloud servers, closing down their 3rd Party Market Place, increasing their prices, and really doubling down on native integrations. Although I think many may disagree here, for groups like us, this seems like a compelling strategy. Their updates seem much more rapid, and their core install looks extremely feature rich. I only found them by looking to see what forum software other game developers are using, and Invision seems the most popular. So Invision may be much more expensive, but not having to dig, search, and beg for solutions here, is a big upside.

Anyway, we are exploring what our options are in this area now that we hit this snag. As the OP said back in 2010 WP is a huge marketplace, and having native integration for it, and putting something in the WP marketplace for Xenforo, would probably boost adoption for XF.
Why don't you contact ThemeHouse? They still offer services and will be happily to support you (if you pay for it ;))
 
Why don't you contact ThemeHouse? They still offer services and will be happily to support you (if you pay for it ;))
Haha, thanks, yes, it is on my queue. Frankly, it would be awesome if they took over the add-on.
 
Last edited:
XFtoWP was perfect for us. Unfortunately, as previously stated, it seems abandoned and errors are starting to pop up as both WP and XF see updates, forcing me to use post necromancy.

After using XF for over a decade, Xenforo relying 3rd party add-ons, becomes more painful as time moves on, as many of them become abandoned. There are some awesome 3rd Party add-on groups here, but unfortunately, for us, it just takes one add-on that is abandoned, to make us rethink viability of keeping XF forums, beyond the standard install. It is disheartening, frankly.
I agree. While third-party addons are wonderful, they should be more trivial add-ons, things to personalize the experience and make life easier.

Some addons such as Donate (Themehouse), E-mail Log (Jack), Logo Essentials (Ozzmodz), XFRM: Resource Download Log (Ozzmodz), Change Content Owner or Date (TickTackk) are essential features that should be offered natively by Xenforo , given its usefulness.

It's really nice to monitor the emails that are being sent to my users. This way I find out when someone has tried to activate their account multiple times simply by monitoring the log. Regarding the log, I really like to monitor who is downloading Resources from my forum, which resource is most popular and when it was downloaded. These are two resources that I use every day.

In addition to them, I also use two others from Ozzmodz, Avatar Gallery (which I also think should be native, just as phpBB has a gallery to speed up choosing a user avatar) and Badges. Badges are very important to me because they also serve as Achievments. Just like Invision has badges, Xenforo does, but through a third-party addon.

I hope these addons are not abandoned. I would be very sad. I try to use few on my forum for exactly the same reason. I want to maintain my forum for many years and I'm afraid the addons I use will eventually be abandoned. I would be very sad to have to give up the features I love so much.
 
A couple things:

1. Invision does not have native integration for this. You must use their OAUTH API, and a third party OAUTH plugin in WordPress, then go through steps to have them connect.

2. Xenforo 2.3, now in Release Candidate 2 status, adds OAUTH.
 
A couple things:

1. Invision does not have native integration for this. You must use their OAUTH API, and a third party OAUTH plugin in WordPress, then go through steps to have them connect.

2. Xenforo 2.3, now in Release Candidate 2 status, adds OAUTH.
Yes, understood with #1.

#2 - Awesome - Maybe this provide the needed solution for us.

Thank you
 
Themehouse had a Wordpress bridge and a native iOS app that were compatible with each other but they’ve moved on to other things it seems.
What had us be less involved here was just the general treatment and unkind nature we were met with from almost everyone (here at the XenForo forums). Elsewhere we continue to actively support anyone using XenForo, just not as much here on this particular forum. It had become a bit of a clique with strange rambles and rants and attacks (though maybe it has improved recently). It was borderline abusive, and things have been so much nicer having stepped back a bit. We're still around though and happily supporting a much smaller list of add-ons, including that XenForo/WP bridge. I think we have around 100 actively in use, and a few that are top 50k by general traffic so in general quite stable.

I still have a place in my heart for XF and look forward to seeing what the XF team has in store! I have high expectations and hopes for 3.0, but entirely understand the sentiment.
 
I'm rather old school here but i think this would work as well.
How about place a link to your wordpress blog on your site instead of getting all these addons?

Because remembering Xenforo has a few updates each year you'd be farting about with addons all the time. When it's a link it's just there and you can reach it.

Sure you can have your site as a wordpress thing if you wish to but the forum has to be seperate.
 
(though maybe it has improved recently)...
Nope, still pretty cut-throat. XenForo core going from the forefront to years with little development, if not stagnancy, has caused insurrection to overflow against a lot of add-on developers undeserving of the unrest. Some really good ones have left, others have slowed their development and offerings. Hopefully with 2.3 & 3.0 around the corner the tide changes and the overall mood and disposition of admins around here improves.

I know at times my posts were/are not always the most courteous due to frustration. Thankfully, I delete the worst of them prior to posting, just writing them helps a little.
 
@bzcomputers Yeah I get that :(. Favoritism was an issue for me too, and with lack of a clear roadmap, impossible to invest without having insider details as some here have. I wouldn't be at all surprised if 3.0 core components or the theme was built by those "favorited" third party resource authors. Maybe wouldn't even be a bad idea to get something out.

The developer community was the best part of xenforo. I am all in favor of trying to bring that back.
 
@bzcomputers Yeah I get that :(. Favoritism was an issue for me too, and with lack of a clear roadmap, impossible to invest without having insider details as some here have. I wouldn't be at all surprised if 3.0 core components or the theme was built by those "favorited" third party resource authors. Maybe wouldn't even be a bad idea to get something out.

The developer community was the best part of xenforo. I am all in favor of trying to bring that back.
I have been here since day one and have seen absolutely no evidence of "favouritism" or "insider details"..?
 


Write your reply...
Back
Top Bottom